Life in the Valley of Death Alan Rabinowitz Reviews
See a Problem?
Thanks for telling us near the problem.
Friend Reviews
Reader Q&A
Exist the kickoff to ask a question about Life in the Valley of Death
Community Reviews
To explore the first part, it is straightforward. Because nether the international media during the 1960s until recently, the military dictatorship in Myanmar is the major thing that has been highlighted.
...moreImpressed nevertheless? Of course you are, unless you lot're some strange mixture of Allan Quartermain and St. Francis and Jane Goodall. In which case, you lot should write a book. That book might be something like Life in the Valley of Death. This is the story of the establishment of the Hukawng Valley Tiger Preserve (the aforementioned largest tiger preserve in the world), and of coming to terms with being diagnosed with incurable leukemia. It is a remarkable story, and it is told in a vocalization that is at once unassuming and brainy, pointed and compassionate.
I'm non saying that the book is perfect. The prose is generally well-crafted but spare, most dry out. There are a few sentences that are out-and-out clumsy. For instance: "I wander from group to group, staying in the shadows, understanding nothing of what is being said, but watching in amazement at the dynamics taking identify." Luckily, sentences like this are few and far in between.
Bad dialogue is a more serious problem. The bespeak of having dialogue in a memoir is to give the reader the impression that they are present at a particular moment of fourth dimension—that the events being described are taking place before their eyes. The more bright the dialogue, the more vivid the effect. The dialogue in Life in the Valley of Decease, unfortunately, frequently sounds a bit artificial. Near the end of the book, for example, Dr. Rabinowitz is attention a meeting between representatives of, variously, the U.Due north. Development Programme, the regime of Myanmar, Kachin Independence Organization leaders, local NGOs, local communities, and Naga insurgents. This is in many ways the climax of the volume, and probably the well-nigh pivotal moment in the establishment of the tiger preserve. Nothing takes you out of the moment quite like a conversation that goes like this:
"It's over," Than Myint says, clearly relieved when the meeting draws to a close. "It went really well," I respond. " We accept some real consensus for moving forwards."
Come on. Who really talks like that?
But for every run-on sentence and unfortunately flat exchange, there are dozens of keenly observed, evocative details and movingly honest moments. Newly diagnosed with leukemia, Dr. Rabinowitz visits the Memorial Sloan-Kettering Cancer Centre to run into with a specialist: "I park five blocks away […:] I linger at a Dunkin Donuts sipping java, not wanting to get closer, not wanting people to call up that I am one of 'them,' another damaged, broken person not every bit good as everyone else." An admission like that takes boggling courage. Later on, the family dog also develops leukemia, and somewhen has to be euthanized. The spareness of the prose works well hither—the parallel between the writer and the animal is articulate but not overstated or manipulative, and the result is quietly devastating.
This sort of resonance runs throughout the book, moving from the personal to the global, and indeed is its main theme. Early in the book, Dr. Rabinowitz stalks a tiger, merely to realize that the tiger has circled around and is now stalking him. Later, he relates the Naga belief in were-tigers: that in that location is an essential affinity between some tigers and men, and so that if the tiger is killed or wounded, the man dies as well. The tiger preserve he establishes encompasses man habitations as well as wilderness. In order to make it work, he has to organize the shipment of medicine and school supplies to impoverished local communities. In effect, he has to conserve local communities too as tigers. This is a model that, he told me over the telephone, he believes should absolutely serve as the future paradigm for global conservation. The tiger is an noon predator, and in order to save them, we need to preserve whole big wild systems. And that cannot be done, Dr. Rabinowitz says, without homo dominated landscapes that too work as multi purpose conservation areas.
The author grew up a severe stutterer. "Every bit a child," he tells me, "I felt like I couldn't talk to people, simply to animals. So I'd come home from schoolhouse and talk to my little New York animals. A turtle, a garter ophidian. I could run across that they had thoughts and feelings—they just couldn't talk. Only similar me. And then I wanted to exist a vox for animals." In Life in the Valley of Death he speaks for animals—and himself—passionately, and extraordinarily well.
...moreThis is a smashing book. Dr. Rabinowitz passion for these cats is amazing. His personal story in the book is and so heart breaking. And thanks to his wonderful wife and friends. He is able to proceed on with this not bad unimaginable dream that at get-go, wasn't something Dr. Rabinowitz thinks tin happen. But with his passion and forcefulness, he fights for this dream to get a reality.
I am looking forward to reading more than of Dr. Rabinowitz' books in the near future.
...moreBut the affair almost it is, the author came across every bit a cocky-important, pompous, egotistical, cocky-aggrandizing jerk for most of the volume. Perchance that's what it takes to attain what he has, simply I don't want to expose myself to this type of personality if I can h
Gosh, anybody loves this book, merely I'm simply not ane of them. Of course, Mr. Rabinowitz is clearly someone that has achieved astonishing things against incredible odds. I mean, who doesn't want to salvage tigers from senseless destruction?But the affair well-nigh it is, the writer came across every bit a self-of import, pompous, egotistical, self-aggrandizing wiggle for most of the book. Maybe that'south what it takes to reach what he has, just I don't want to expose myself to this type of personality if I tin can help it. I should have given upward on the book instead of struggling through to the end.
As a last note, I think that I threw up in my mouth a lilliputian scrap when the author describes his late mother as a "simple housewife." That'south all you take to say? Really?
...moreMyanmar is a country of political turmoil and a troubled history... and home to its own tiger population. Naturalist Alan Rabinowitz has committed himself to saving these creatures, and works hard with local government officials to discover how many tigers are left in the country and how best to relieve them. But Myanmar is facing tremendous upheaval, with the authorities shaky at best and facing brutal coups at worst, and the discovery of gilt in the country results in a rush to strip the landscape blank of this precious metal at the expense of the tigers and other animals that live there. And equally Alan strives to establish a protected area for the tigers, he also faces a cancer diagnosis that forces him to come to terms with his own health and mortality.
The writing in this book is serviceable, if a bit dry and repetitive in places. Alan goes into dandy depth regarding the often-disregarded land of Myanmar and its troubled history, and manages to tie his own by and personal life into the story without making this book entirely self-indulgent. There are a few places where it feels similar he uses the wrong word to get his indicate beyond, and some odd typos here and in that location, but perhaps a subsequently edition can correct these goofs.
Alan manages to requite us a compelling account of the tigers of Myanmar and the efforts to save them without vilifying the humans who are trying to survive alongside these creatures. Also ofttimes in a conservation-minded book like this humans are vilified as being greedy or sheer evil, merely Alan makes it clear that about of the people who are exploiting the tiger's habitat are but trying to survive too, and that decisions need to be made that will do good both parties instead of just serving one over the other. He shows that at that place are never easy, clear-cut answers when information technology comes to conservation efforts, and that these issues are more complex than people want to believe.
This book is rather bloodshot to read, specially the sections dealing with Rabinowitz's cancer -- he passed away in 2018 from the very cancer he'due south diagnosed with in this book. Just it's a fascinating look at a land and its large cats, and the struggle to salve them.
...more thanThe writing is mostly fine - I concur with the reviewers who have noted the bizarre mode that Rabinowitz handles dialogue that seems
This is a hell of a style to brand/market a book that is ii/3rds about navigating Burmese bureaucracy, and 1/tertiary a memoir of some actually rotten stuff that happens to the author. I get that there's a point to be fabricated that conversation is really well-nigh conversations happening in closed rooms between powerful people, just...information technology'south just no tigers in this volume about tigers, human.The writing is mostly fine - I agree with the reviewers who take noted the bizarre manner that Rabinowitz handles dialogue that seems at best "simplified" from real conversations - and there are genuinely touching moments. But overall, this book feels uncommitted to whatsoever of the potential things information technology could be. I came away agreement a fleck better the complicated politics of pushing forrard conservation, and hearing the author's rebuttal to those who say that working with repressive regimes on conservation enables and legitimizes them. I learned about how some hard personal stuff he worked through. I occasionally got a glimpse of field work in Myanmar, and some mostly sympathetic portrayals of different indigenous people. Only the book veers in like five directions, never commits to i, and feels less whole for having done and then.
...more thanThis was an interesting read, and an upwards-close-and-personal wait at what being a wild fauna abet in a foreign land actually involves. I besides learned quite a bit
This is the story of how writer and wildlife scientist Alan Rabinowitz worked with the government and peoples of Myanmar to establish the globe'south largest tiger reserve. He details the inner workings of the various government agencies, the various insurgent groups in the country, and his own family as he worked to set up the reserve.This was an interesting read, and an up-close-and-personal look at what being a wildlife advocate in a strange country really involves. I also learned quite a bit about conservation efforts in poor areas--especially how they must piece of work with the people there to find solutions that benefit them and the wild fauna in the area.
...moreI liked Mr Alan perseverance. His oh of tigers and wild fauna is inspiring. If you similar animals & people you volition like this book. Well documented.
Mr. Rabinowitz has his ain style of writing: while he doesn't present his story in original, colorful images, his paragraphs are very rich in detail and provide the reader with a thorough picture. His descriptions are usually straight to the betoken. Sometimes they are delivered with a chip of humor: "…since several of our elephant handlers, called mahouts, are fond to opium, an early forenoon start is not function of their repertoire." Other times, you can easily see what is in his heart. For example, he states that the life expectancy of an elephant is "…shortened considerably when 'white gold' protrudes from your head."
This is an splendid book, revealing one man's passion for effecting positive alter and the difficulties he encountered during his multi-yr mission.
...moreThis book is not edge-of-your-seat reading, only it is interesting and motivating.
...moreThe volume opened my optics to the more far-reaching conservation efforts of the organization and especially its founder. Particularly impressive is his power to be simultaneously detached and emotional.
Loved this book!
The Story of the struggles of a small group who fought to save and protect the dwindling number of Tigers of Burma.
Although I take never coordinated nor managed a project such every bit the valley, trying to coordinate with all the entities, governmental, communities, etc. I really enjoyed learning of the difficulties and of the ultimate success working to relieve the tiger.
topics | posts | views | final activity | |
---|---|---|---|---|
Setting | 1 | half dozen | Jan 28, 2009 05:06PM |
News & Interviews
Welcome back. Just a moment while we sign you in to your Goodreads account.
Source: https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/1278226.Life_in_the_Valley_of_Death